How Do We Reason?

 

How do we reason with each other in our daily lives? We probably state some facts and then state a conclusion based on the facts. For example, the words and the phrase in the following list are often used to indicate that some kind of conclusion is being made:

therefore, thus, whence, so, ergo, hence, it follows that.

When we state a conclusion of some kind, we are applying a rule of logic called an inference rule.

The most common rule of inference is called modus ponens, and it works like this: Suppose A and Ð’ are two statements and we assume that A and "If A then B" are both true. We can then infer that Ð’ is true. A typical example of inference by modus ponens is given by the following three sentences:

 

If it is raining, then there are clouds in the sky.

It is raining.

Therefore there are clouds in the sky.

 

We use the modus ponens inference rule without thinking about it. We certainly learned it when we were children, probably by testing a parent. For example, if a child receives a hug from a parent after performing some action, it might dawn on the child that the hug follows after the action. The parent might reinforce the situation by saying, "If you do that again, then you will be rewarded." Parents often make statements such as "If you touch that stove burner, then you will burn your finger." After touching the burner, the child probably knows a little bit more about modus ponens. A parent might say, "If you do that again, then you are going to be punished." The normal child probably will do it again and notice that punishment follows. Eventually, in the child's mind, the statement "If... then ... punishment" is accepted as a true statement, and the modus ponens rule has taken root.

Another inference rule, which we also learned when we were children, is called modus tollens, and it works like this: Suppose A and Ð’ are any two statements. If the statement "If A then B" is true and the statement Ð’ is false, then we infer the falsity of statement A. A child might learn this rule initially by thinking, "If I'm not being punished, then I must not be doing anything wrong."

Most of us are also familiar with the false reasoning exhibited by the non sequitur, which means "It does not follow." For example, someone might make several true statements and then conclude that some other statement is true, even though it has nothing to do with the assumptions. The hope is that we can recognize this kind of false reasoning so that we never use it. For example, the following three sentences form a non sequitur:

 

Io is a moon of Jupiter.

Titan is a moon of Saturn.

Therefore Earth is the third planet from the sun.

 

Here's another example of a non sequitur:

 

You squandered the money entrusted to you.

You did not keep required records.

You incurred more debt than your department is worth.

Therefore you deserve a promotion.

 

So we reason by applying inference rules to sentences that we assume are true, obtaining new sentences that we conclude are true. Each of us has our own personal reasoning system in which the assumptions are those English sentences that we assume are true and the inference rules are all the rules that we personally use to convince other people that something is true. But there's a problem.

When two people disagree on what they assume to be true or on how they reason about things, then they have problems trying to reason with each other. Some people call this "lack of communication." Other people call it something worse, especially when things like non sequiturs are part of a person's reasoning system. Can common ground be found? Are there any reasoning systems that are, or should be, contained in everyone's personal reasoning system? The answer is yes. The study of logic helps us understand and describe the fundamental parts of all reasoning systems.